Auto Accident Lawyers Serving Port Charlotte, Fort Myers, and Southwest Florida

After a serious car accident, most people are dealing with medical appointments, missed work, and insurance adjusters within days. For more than 35 years, All Injuries Law Firm, P.A. has helped people across Port Charlotte, Fort Myers, Sarasota, and surrounding communities regain stability after serious auto accidents.

Our firm handles injury cases exclusively. That focus matters. Auto accident claims in Florida are shaped by no-fault insurance rules, comparative negligence laws, and strict time limits. Knowing how those pieces work together — and how insurance carriers use them — is critical to protecting your claim.

What to Expect When You Call All Injuries Law Firm

• A free consultation focused on what happened, your injuries, and immediate concerns
• Clear explanations of insurance coverage, deadlines, and next steps
• Our team handling insurance communications so you can focus on recovery
• Ongoing updates as medical records, evidence, and coverage details develop

A Local Auto Accident Law Firm With a Record of Results

All Injuries Law Firm has represented thousands of injured Floridians since the late 1980s. Our attorneys have secured multiple million-dollar and high six-figure recoveries, including significant results in auto accident cases involving serious and permanent injuries. You can view more examples on our case results page.

Notable auto-related recoveries include:

• $1.5 million – auto accident involving multiple injuries
• $1.1 million – knee injury caused by a negligent driver
• $1 million – automobile accident resulting in back injury
• $879,000 – severe injury from a motor-vehicle collision
• $845,000 – neck injury from a car crash

Many of these outcomes required layered insurance analysis, coordination with treating physicians, and extended negotiations after insurers initially disputed fault or the seriousness of the injuries.

Common Insurance Issues We See in Southwest Florida Crashes

• Limited or missing bodily injury coverage on the at-fault driver’s policy
• Uninsured or underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) questions, including stacked vs. non-stacked coverage
• Blame-shifting between multiple drivers in chain-reaction crashes
• Passengers competing for the same insurance limits
• Pressure to settle before the full extent of injuries is known

What Makes Auto Accident Cases in Florida Complicated

No-Fault (PIP) Insurance Comes First
Most injured drivers and passengers must first turn to Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits, regardless of fault. PIP only covers a portion of medical bills and lost wages and does not compensate for pain and suffering.

The Serious Injury Threshold
To pursue full compensation — including pain, suffering, and long-term impact — injuries generally must meet Florida’s statutory threshold, such as permanent injury, significant scarring, loss of bodily function, or death.

Comparative Negligence Rules
Florida now follows a modified comparative negligence system. If an injured person is found more than 50% at fault, recovery may be barred. Insurance companies aggressively use this rule to shift blame and reduce payouts.

Our attorneys evaluate these issues early, before mistakes are made that insurers later exploit.

Types of Auto Accident Cases We Handle

Our auto accident practice includes, but is not limited to:

• Rear-end and intersection collisions
• Multi-vehicle and chain-reaction crashes
• Single-vehicle accidents involving passengers
• Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims
• Serious injury crashes involving spine, brain, or orthopedic trauma
• Wrongful death resulting from motor-vehicle collisions

Many of these cases involve hidden insurance coverage, disputed fault, or multiple responsible parties. Identifying every potential source of recovery is part of our process.

How Insurance Companies Approach Car Accident Claims

Several members of our legal team understand insurance strategy from the inside. Attorney Bryan Greenberg previously worked at a large insurance defense firm representing insurers and employers. That experience informs how our firm approaches auto accident cases today. You can learn more about him here: Attorney Bryan Greenberg.

Insurers often:

• Push early statements before injuries are fully understood
• Rely on crash reports or partial facts to assign blame
• Minimize long-term medical needs
• Pressure injured people to settle before full treatment is complete

We step in early to protect clients from these tactics and build claims based on medical evidence, accident reconstruction, and full documentation of losses.

“In the first days after a crash, what matters most is preserving evidence, understanding the available insurance coverage, and making sure medical care is properly documented. Those early decisions can shape the entire case.”
— Corbin Sutter, Auto Accident Attorney

Attorneys Focused on Auto Accident Injuries

Brian O. Sutter, Managing Partner, has practiced Florida injury law for more than 35 years and is board-certified by The Florida Bar. Learn more: Attorney Brian O. Sutter.

Corbin Sutter focuses his practice on personal injury and auto accident cases and is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Learn more: Attorney Corbin Sutter.

Jenna Kakley represents injured clients in complex personal injury matters, bringing strong litigation skills and a client-centered approach to auto accident cases. Learn more: Attorney Jenna Kakley.

Our attorneys regularly handle auto accident cases involving limited insurance coverage, disputed fault, and injuries that do not fully reveal themselves until weeks or months after a crash.

What Compensation May Be Available After a Car Accident

Depending on the facts of the case, compensation may include:

• Past and future medical expenses
• Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
• Physical pain and emotional suffering
• Costs of rehabilitation and long-term care
• Permanent disability or disfigurement
• Wrongful death damages for surviving families

No two auto accident cases unfold the same way, particularly when insurance coverage and medical recovery develop over time. We focus on building claims that reflect the real, long-term impact of an accident — not just immediate bills.

Serving Clients Across Southwest Florida

With offices in Port Charlotte and Fort Myers, we serve injured clients throughout Charlotte, Lee, and Sarasota counties. Consultations are available locally and by phone, and our attorneys regularly handle cases arising from crashes on I-75, US-41, and other major Southwest Florida roadways.

We represent neighbors, families, and workers throughout Charlotte, Lee, and Sarasota counties, and our attorneys practice in the same courts and communities where these cases are decided.

Victory for the Injured

Victory isn’t only about a settlement or verdict. It’s about medical care being paid, financial pressure easing, and families regaining peace of mind.

At All Injuries Law Firm, we even have a tradition — when clients resolve their case successfully, they ring the Victory Gong. It’s a small moment, but it represents something bigger: moving forward.

Speak With a Southwest Florida Auto Accident Lawyer

If you or a loved one has been injured in a car accident, you don’t have to navigate Florida’s insurance and injury laws alone. We offer free consultations and will explain your options clearly and honestly.

Call (941) 625-4878 or contact All Injuries Law Firm to see what victory can look like for you.